Notes on nabataean construction techniques : a critical review and investigation of el-khazneh slots function

Part of : Mediterranean archaeology & archaeometry : international journal ; Vol.15, No.3, 2015, pages 17-30

Issue:
Pages:
17-30
Author:
Abstract:
The Nabataeans were highly creative in their adaptation of the Greco-Roman construction techniques. Based on their specific natural resources and lexicon of architectural elements, the Nabataeans thus developed their own techniques. Indeed, the size and elaborate nature of many of their monuments would require such innovations, as physically manifested in the two vertical rows of slots located on the recessed back face wall on either side of the façade of el-Khazneh in Petra in Jordan. These slots have been a matter of some debate on whether their function was for footholds or for scaffolding. Though the slots have been discussed in passing, no scholar has made the in-depth critical investigation in determining their proper technical and functional approach with reference to their preserved fully recorded dimensions. Thanks to a recent study using a combination of 3D laser scanner and reflector-less total station, we now have precise measurements of the well preserved individual slots. This article is concerned with the particular case of these slots. A detailed examination of these slots in relation to their size and depth, position and arrangement within the façade, probably credits their use, both, as foot holes, and as supports for a smart and simple scaffolding structure. The paper suggests and exemplifies that, these slots are part of an authentic Nabataean construction technique, and they were the foundations used to fix a wooden lightweight socket in a diagonal changeabla cantilever scaffolding. This new assumption is supported with schematic sections and illustrations showing alternative combinations of the cantilever scaffolding at different slot heights, using the embedded putlog and diagonal bracing on which the planks are held. Thus, providing the basis for further research, hopefully encouraging a further knowledge of Nabataean scaffolding construction techniques of rock-cut architecture.
Subject:
Subject (LC):
Keywords:
Rock-cut architecture, Socketed diagonal cantilever scaffolding, Putlogs, Nabataean Architecture, Construction techniques, el-Khazneh
References (1):
  1. Adam, J-P.(1984) La construction romaine : Matériaux et techniques. A éd. Paris: Picard.Bessac, J-C. and Nehmé, L. ( 2007) Le Travail de la pierre à Petra — Technique et economie de la taille rupestre, Paris: Éditions Recherche sur les civilisations.Al-Salameen, Z (2008) The Nabateans and Lycians. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry, Vol. 8, No. 2, 21-29.Al‐Salameen, Z. (2011) The Nabataeans and Asia Minor, Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry, Vol. 11, No. 2, 55‐78.Besancon, A. (2000) The Forbidden Image. Chicago: Chicago University Press.Browning, I.( 1973) Petra. 1st ed. London: Chatto and Windus.Browning, I. (1982) Petra. Rev. ed. London: Chatto and Windus.Brünnow, R.E. and von Domaszewski, A. (1904) Die Provincia Arabia. Vol. 1, Strassburg: Trübner.Dalley, S. and Goguel, A. (1997) The Sela’ Sculpture: a New-Babylonian Rock Relief in Southern Jordan, Annual of the Department of Antiquities of Jordan, Vol. 41, 169-77.Dodgeq, H. (1984) Building Materials and Technique in the Eastern Mediterranean from the Hellenistic Period to the Fourth Century AD. PhD Thesis. University of Newcastle.Farajat, S. and Nawafleh, S. (2005) Report on the al-Khazna courtyard excavations at Petra (2003 Season), Annual of the Department of Antiquities of Jordan, Vol. 49, 373–393.Kanellopoulos, Ch.(2004) The Temples of Petra: An Architectural Analysis, Archäologische Anziger ,Vol. 1, 221-239.Kennedy, A. (1925) Petra: Its History and Monuments. London: Country Life.Haddad, N. (1999) Macedonia, Alexandria, Petra: Tomb Architecture, In: International Congress, Alexander The Great: From Macedonia to the Oikoumene, Veria, 27–31. 5. 1998 , Nomarchiake Autodioikese Hemathias, Greece, 161-171.Haddad, N. (2012) Aspects of the Particularity and Creativity of the Nabataean Architectural Culture during the Late Hellenistic and Roman period, In The First International Conference of the Nabataean Culture, Petra: 5 – 8 May 2012.(In press).Haddad, N. and Ishakat, F. ( 2007) 3D Laser Scanner and Reflectorless Total Station: A Comparative Study of the Slots of El-Khazneh at Petra in Jordan, In The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, 36,5/C53, (October 2007), 356- 361.Hammond, P.C. (1973) The Nabataeans – Their History, Culture and Archaeology. Gottenburg: Paul Äströms.Khairy, N. (2011) The Mada’in Saleh Monuments and the Function and Date of the Khazneh in Petra, Palestine Exploration Quarterly, Vol. 143, No. 3, 167–175.Kühlenthal, M. and Fisher, H. (2000) Petra. The Restoration of the Rockcut Tomb Facade: German-Jordanian Project for the Establishment of a Conversation Center in Petra. Munich: Karl M. Lipp.Lauter, H. (1971) Ptolemais in Libyen: Ein Beitrag zur Baukunst Alexandrias, Jahrbuch des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts , Vol. 86, 149-78.Liritzis, I, Alotaibi, F.M, Castro, B, Drivaliari, A (2015) Nabatean tombs orientation by remote sensing: Provisional results. Mediterranean Archaeology & Archaeometry, Vol.15, No.3, 289-299.Lyttelton, M. (1974) Baroque Architecture in Classical Antiquity. London: Thames and Hudson.McKenzie, J.(1990) The Architecture of Petra. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.Netzer, E.( 2003) Nabatäische Architektur. Mainz: von Zabern.Parr, P. (1968) The Investigation of Some ‘inaccessible’ Rock-cut Chambers at Petra. Palestine Exploration Quarterly , Vol. 100, 5-16.Pflüger, F. (1995) Archaeo-Geology in Petra, Jordan. Annual of the Department of Antiquities of Jordan, Vol. 39, 281-97.Rababeh, Sh. M. (2005) How Petra was Built, British Archaeological Reports International Series 1460. Oxford.Schmid, S. (2001) The Nabataeans: Travellers between Life Styles, Levantine Archaeology I. The Archaeology of Jordan, 367-426. ed. B. MacDonald, R. Adams, and P. Bienkowski. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press.Shaer, M. (2005) The Decorative Architectural Surfaces of Petra, PhD Thesis, Technische Universität München.Shaer, M. and Aslan, Z. (1997) Architectural Investigation on the Building Techniques of the Nabataeans with Reference to Tomb 825. Annual of the Department of Antiquities of Jordan, Vol. 41, 219-31.Shaer, M. and Aslan, Z. (2000) Nabataean Building Techniques with Special References to the Architecture of Tomb 825 (Tomb of Fourteen Graves), eds. Kühlenthal and Fisher, 89-109.Wadeson, L. (2010) The Chronology of the Façade Tombs at Petra: a Structural and Metrical Analysis, Levant, Vol. 42, No. 1, 48-69.Wadeson, L. (2011) Nabataean tomb complexes at Petra: new insights in the light of recent fieldwork. http://www.ascs.org.au/news/ascs32/Wadeson.pdfWenning, R. (2003) The Rock-Cut Architecture of Petra”, Markoe, 133-43.Will, E. and Larché, F. (1991) Iraq Al-Amir, Le château du Tobiad Hyrcan. Paris: Libraire Orientaliste Paul Geuthner.Wright, G.R.H. (2009) Ancient Building Technology, Vol. 3, Brill.